The problem with the door pulls is the material which all the stress is directed is plastic and thin, and it is used every time you close the door, so it is going to fail at some point. After looking for a replacement, new (absurd pricing around $200) and used (almost as much a new one), I decided to try and repair the original. I repaired my drivers side with a combination of "plastic weld", reinforcement, and an additional screw to spread the load. The reinforcement consisted of creating a small sheet metal "tab" to sit in the pocket where screw goes (to help spread the load), a small washer may work if the plastic is not yet damaged. Additionally I added a pair of cut-off wire brads between the 2 broken pieces of plastic to help hold the pieces together for the plastic weld, I applied the plastic weld on both sides of the screw pocket with the reinforcements in place. Before I reinstalled the door card I added an additional screw with an oversized (fender) washer from the backside of the door card into the top section of the door pull to help spread the load on the pull to both the door card and the original screw. I can say that after the repair, the door pull has never felt stronger and it convinced me to proactively reinforce the passenger side pull as well before it could fail.