Installing replacement Window regulator - My experience !

Matt Barnes

Zorg Guru (II)
Supporter
British Zeds
Joined
Jul 18, 2020
Points
123
Location
Portchester, Fareham
Model of Z
1998 BMW Z3 Individual 1.9 M44 B19
Afternoon all !... so today I tried dodging the showers in order to fit a replacement driver window regulator... all good but made a couple of cock ups on the way which cost me a bit of time.... and I also fitted my patent pending metal putty repair door handle !

Standard fare in removing trim...... when removing the glass, I DIDN'T follow one bloke on youtube who suggested you just pop the clips on the runners and lift it out. I listened to someone else who removed the quarter light first and then SLID the glass off the runners... SOSO much easier..... then closed the scissors to ease it out of the aperture....
1682177277310.jpeg


I knew that one of the door studs had broken off, and the bolt hole of the regulator had sheered off, which was a bit of a pain ! Evidently that one fails a lot, as when the window reaches the top, the regulator actually pushes down on that bracket

1682177351877.jpeg


the Stud actually has a square recess and it looks like it's almost riveted into the bracket rather than welded.

1682177491578.jpeg

1682177504249.jpeg


so it was out with my new best friend METAL PUTTY. which I used for the door handle repair...slid the stud back into the square groove and basically covered the whole thing with metal putty, and let it set for an hour... it actually does go rock hard.

1682177554993.jpeg


I know it seems obvious but.... I found when putting in the window slider clips...turn them 90 degrees and it makes it SO much easier to clip them in...then just turn them back round afterwards
1682177794075.jpeg


So the replacement regulator went in.... up and down as smooth as silk.... and the putty laden stud held up

1682177699347.jpeg


I might need to get new door seals because as soon as I put everything back, the glass was dragging on the seals and I could hear the motor struggling to overcome it... managed to widen the seals with a wide blade screwdriver to ease the drag but it's still not perfect.

I managed to cock up a little by fitting the quarterlight before the glass.... idiot !!.... so after faffing with that, I took it back out again so I could get the window in and SLIDE it back into the plastic runners.... then fitted the quarter light AGAIN... then fettled with the door card......but we're there ...all done...I'll let you know how the handle holds up !

1682178099202.jpeg
 

t-tony

Zorg Expert (II)
Supporter
British Zeds
#ZedShed
Joined
Dec 31, 2013
Points
226
Location
Torksey Lock,Lincoln, England
Model of Z
E89 Z4 23i Auto
Apply some silicone spray to the rubber slide channels, it makes such a difference. This tightness, in part, is what snaps that stud off the door. I repaired that particular fault on a Z by using a 6mm bolt slipped into the original hole and fixed with a nut and washer. I just added plain nuts up to the length of the spacer on the original stud. Then a nylon nut on after the regulator lug. I doubt that putty repair will last long.

Tony.

ps. If I were at home I would make a mock up to show you what I mean.
 

Matt Barnes

Zorg Guru (II)
Supporter
British Zeds
Joined
Jul 18, 2020
Points
123
Location
Portchester, Fareham
Model of Z
1998 BMW Z3 Individual 1.9 M44 B19
Apply some silicone spray to the rubber slide channels, it makes such a difference. This tightness, in part, is what snaps that stud off the door. I repaired that particular fault on a Z by using a 6mm bolt slipped into the original hole and fixed with a nut and washer. I just added plain nuts up to the length of the spacer on the original stud. Then a nylon nut on after the regulator lug. I doubt that putty repair will last long.

Tony.

ps. If I were at home I would make a mock up to show you what I mean.
cheers Tony..I have seen someone knock up that bracket on youtube, but would be interested in your solution.. ..I squirted lithium grease down the quarter light pillar, but it seems to be pinching more near the door lock...
 

t-tony

Zorg Expert (II)
Supporter
British Zeds
#ZedShed
Joined
Dec 31, 2013
Points
226
Location
Torksey Lock,Lincoln, England
Model of Z
E89 Z4 23i Auto
cheers Tony..I have seen someone knock up that bracket on youtube, but would be interested in your solution.. ..I squirted lithium grease down the quarter light pillar, but it seems to be pinching more near the door lock...
Happy to, but it will be quite a while till we're home Matt.
 

Matt Barnes

Zorg Guru (II)
Supporter
British Zeds
Joined
Jul 18, 2020
Points
123
Location
Portchester, Fareham
Model of Z
1998 BMW Z3 Individual 1.9 M44 B19
update on my "quick" window regulator bracket fix using Metal Putty...... @t-tony your prediction came true... after a week it snapped off !.....

1682783003476.png

so I decided to make up a bracket from an old shelf bracket

1682783064646.png

1682783094189.png


so now it's solid..... and hopefully no more snapping regulator mounts !!
1682783192227.png
 

Oddly Godly

Zorg Guru (III)
Supporter
British Zeds
Joined
May 17, 2019
Points
129
Location
dunstable
Model of Z
z3 2.8
Glad it's sorted. As you must now be an expert on refitting the door card how easy was it. I've heard it can be a bit of a pig to get back in place
 

Matt Barnes

Zorg Guru (II)
Supporter
British Zeds
Joined
Jul 18, 2020
Points
123
Location
Portchester, Fareham
Model of Z
1998 BMW Z3 Individual 1.9 M44 B19
Glad it's sorted. As you must now be an expert on refitting the door card how easy was it. I've heard it can be a bit of a pig to get back in place
I found clipping the inner window seal on the door card BEFORE fitting it to the door far easier than trying to hook the card onto the seal...
 
Top